Can black tire “covers” be used without causing damage?

Can black tire “covers” be used without causing damage?

RV Tire Safety
with RV tire expert Roger Marble

Back in June 2011, I did a post that asked the question: “Tire Covers – Do they do any good?” In that post I showed the numbers from a test I had run where I collected tire temperatures showing the effects of shielding my tires with white vinyl covers versus the tire temperature when exposed to direct sunlight for just a couple of hours.

I also covered the science of the damage that excess heat can do to our tires. The bottom line of that post was that white vinyl can help extend the life of tires by protecting them from both the effects of UV and the, in my opinion, more serious damage done to the internal structure of tires from excess heat.

I also did a rough check using dark trash bag covering a tire and in that case I found that the black cover actually resulted in a tire being hotter than when it was just in the sun with no cover. Based on that limited data I have recommended against the use of black or dark color vinyl tire covers.

On more than one occasion I have observed some Class A RVs with what appears to be a mesh shield that hangs down off the side of the RV. This is different than the vinyl “bag” that hangs directly over the outside of my tires. I was able to collect a few data points while in Redmond, Ore., in 2014 at a large RV convention, and that data suggested it might be possible to use this mesh material and not increase the temperature of the tires.

Finally, this summer while at another RV convention I struck up a conversation with a representative of ShadePro, Inc., who offered to send me a Tire Shade to test. In August and September, I had some health issues and then I ran into difficulty with clouds here in northeast Ohio, but I was finally able to collect the data I felt comfortable with that would allow me to reach a conclusion of if this black mesh material could be used.

Here is a shot of my test setup with a white vinyl on front, control sidewall in center and the black mesh shielding the rear. After two hours of sun, in the shade a tire gave a reading of 92°F, while in the sun the white cover was 126°F. The reference tire sidewall registered at 147°F, and the black mesh shade showed 136°F. Under the cover the front tire was at 114°, while behind the mesh shade the rear tire was only 101°F. (Click here to see photos of the temperature readings.)

Conclusion:
The data shows that in this test the black mesh did a better job of keeping the tire cool than the white vinyl.

I can think of a couple of reasons for this:
1. The vinyl cover was in direct contact with the front tire so heat was being directly transferred to the tire.
2. The mesh allowed better air circulation around the rear tire.
3. The fact that the black plastic was also in direct contact with the tire probably contributed to the poor results.

Observation:
I was wrong to suggest that all black shields were worse than white covers, as this test shows that data is better than opinion when it comes to facts. This is one of the wonderful things about science. 

Read more from Roger Marble on his blog at RVtiresafety.net.

##RVT815

 

 

Facebooktwitterpinteresttumblrmail

Related

6 thoughts on “Can black tire “covers” be used without causing damage?

  1. Sherry Dawson

    What this company markets on the website is not what you tested. Their actual consumer product does not have as much air circulation–it is attached to the rig at top and sides and the bottom is weighted to sit on the ground. The only air circulation is a few inches at the bottom. Perhaps you can test the actual consumer product and let us know your opinion.

  2. Dennis

    Anyone with a Class A and uses the Black Mesh covers on the windshield will tell you with these installed the interior Temperature of the coach will drop by at least 10-15 degrees. They are Very Effective.
    The tire shades are made of the same material and most often, as in my case, were purchased as a custom made set with the windshield cover.

  3. Robbie

    Interesting that we now have to defend science.

    1. Lee Ensminger

      You mean because the “science” or “scientists” of any given period of time have never been wrong?

  4. Ray

    I thought the issue was UV damage not heat? Most material protects tires from UV light. I use white plastic covers which don’t absorb heat as much.

  5. John M

    I disagree with Roger as in the test he said he used black plastic bags, the question was black vinyl I have used the white vinyl for years and had good results with my tires. I am now using black vinyl and will see how they do. I do think if your covers are to tight that they could raise the temp up more that if they are one size bigger to let air in around them

Leave a Comment